FantasyAtlasHome › Playoff Fantasy Football › Best Sites › NFL Playoff Challenge Alternative
Looking for the NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge? Here Are the Alternatives
Last updated: November 2026 · Competitor details checked November 2026 from each provider's public pages
The NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge was discontinued for the 2024-25 season, per the NFL Support Center, and we have not seen an announcement that it has returned. If your group used to play it every January, here are the closest replacements for this postseason, free and paid.
What happened to the NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge?
The NFL Support Center states that the NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge was discontinued for the 2024-25 season. We have not seen an announcement that it is back (checked November 2026). If it returns, we'll update this page.
Free alternatives you can play with friends
One-and-Done
The lowest-effort replacement. Pick one player per playoff round, never the same player twice. No draft.
How it works →Snake Draft League
Draft a full roster with friends before Wild Card Weekend and set lineups each round.
How it works →Bracket Pool
Pick the winner of every playoff game and score points as the bracket plays out.
How it works →All three run on FantasyAtlas and are free to play. MyFantasyLeague also offers free playoff leagues if you want to build a custom total-points format.
Paid alternatives
- FFPC Playoff Challenge: pick one player per playoff team for a 12-man roster, which means skipping two playoff teams entirely; Super Bowl scoring is doubled. $200 entry with a $500,000 grand prize (2025-26 official rules); a lower-cost version ran at $35.
- Underdog Fantasy: playoff best ball tournaments; last postseason's ranged from $5 to $25.
- NFFC Post Season Hold 'Em: weekly rosters with hold multipliers, $50 to $200.
See the full breakdown in Best Playoff Fantasy Football Sites & Apps.
Sources (checked November 2026): NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge: support.nfl.com "Playoff Challenge" article. FFPC Playoff Challenge: myffpc.com official rules (2025-26) and Roto Street Journal (Jan 2026). Underdog Fantasy: Roto Street Journal, "Where and How to Play NFL Playoffs Fantasy Football and Best Ball (2026)", plus prior-season contest coverage. NFFC Post Season Hold 'Em: Roto Street Journal (Jan 2026). MyFantasyLeague: home.myfantasyleague.com/nfl-playoff-leagues.html and the MFL Help Center. Prices and rules change each postseason, so confirm on each provider's site before you enter. All trademarks belong to their owners; FantasyAtlas is not affiliated with any of the companies named here.
How to move your group over in two minutes
Create a free account
Sign up on FantasyAtlas.
Pick a format
One-and-Done is the closest "just make picks" experience; a Snake Draft League adds a live draft.
Share the invite link
Drop it in the group chat before Wild Card Weekend locks.
Set up your playoff league before Wild Card Weekend
Free to create, free to join. Takes about a minute.
Sign Up FreeFrequently asked questions
Is the NFL Fantasy Playoff Challenge coming back?
The NFL Support Center says it was discontinued for the 2024-25 season. As of November 2026 we have not seen an announcement that it has returned.
What is the best free alternative to the NFL Playoff Challenge?
FantasyAtlas offers three free playoff-only formats: One-and-Done (one player per round, no draft), a Snake Draft League with friends, and a Bracket Pool. MyFantasyLeague also offers free custom playoff leagues.
Is there a paid version with prizes?
Yes. The FFPC Playoff Challenge, Underdog Fantasy playoff best ball, and NFFC Post Season Hold 'Em are paid contests with cash prizes. Eligibility depends on your age and state.